The $8,000 Question
Tesla's Full Self-Driving package costs $8,000 upfront or $99/month. With adoption rates dropping from 50% to 14%, many buyers are questioning its value. Let's analyze whether FSD is worth the investment for your situation.
Pricing Options
One-Time Purchase
- Permanent ownership
- Transfers with vehicle when sold
- 48-hour refund window
- All future software updates
- High upfront cost
- Depreciates significantly (only adds ~$3,000 to resale)
Monthly Subscription
- Cancel anytime
- Try before committing
- Lower initial cost
- All software updates
- Costs more over time ($1,188/year)
- Doesn't transfer with vehicle
What FSD Includes
Current Features (2025)
- Navigate on Autopilot (highway lane changes, exits)
- Auto Lane Change (on highways and city streets)
- Autopark (parallel and perpendicular parking)
- Summon (move car in/out of tight spaces)
- Smart Summon (come to you in parking lots)
- Traffic Light and Stop Sign Control
- City Streets Navigation (supervised driving on local roads)
Important: FSD is Level 2 Automation
Despite the name, FSD requires constant driver supervision. You must keep your hands on the wheel and be ready to take control at any moment. It's an advanced driver assistance system, not autonomous driving.
Real-World Cost Analysis
Meet David: Subscription vs Purchase
David commutes 50 miles daily and takes 3 road trips per year. He wants FSD for highway driving but isn't sure about the long-term value.
Subscription Strategy
- • Subscribes for 3 months during road trip season: $297/year
- • Uses basic Autopilot for daily commute (included free)
- • Total 5-year cost: $1,485
Purchase Strategy
- • One-time purchase: $8,000
- • Adds ~$3,000 to resale value after 5 years
- • Net cost: $5,000
David's Decision
David chose the subscription model, saving $3,515 over 5 years. He only pays for FSD when he needs it most, and basic Autopilot handles his daily commute perfectly.
Subscription vs Purchase Break-Even
| Time Period | Subscription Cost | Purchase Net Cost | Better Option |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Year | $1,188 | $8,000 | Subscription |
| 3 Years | $3,564 | $6,500* | Subscription |
| 5 Years | $5,940 | $5,000* | Purchase |
| 7 Years | $8,316 | $5,000* | Purchase |
| 10 Years | $11,880 | $5,000* | Purchase |
Who Should Buy FSD?
Good Fit For
- Long-term owners (5+ years)
- Frequent highway drivers
- Tech enthusiasts who value cutting-edge features
- Those who can afford the upfront cost
- Drivers with long, monotonous commutes
Better to Skip
- Short-term owners (under 3 years)
- Mostly city drivers with short trips
- Budget-conscious buyers
- Those who enjoy driving manually
- Buyers planning to resell soon (poor ROI)
The Verdict
For most buyers, the $99/month subscription is the smarter choice. It lets you try FSD without commitment and only pay when you need it. Basic Autopilot (included free) handles highway driving well enough for daily use.
The $8,000 purchase only makes financial sense if you plan to keep your Tesla for 5+ years and use FSD features daily. Even then, you'll lose about $5,000 in depreciation, as FSD only adds ~$3,000 to resale value.
Remember: FSD is still supervised driving. You must stay alert and ready to take control. It's a convenience feature, not true self-driving, despite the name.
Frequently Asked Questions
Related Articles
Model 3 vs Model Y
Compare Tesla's two most popular models to find the perfect fit for your needs.
Extended Warranty Guide
Learn about Tesla's Extended Service Agreement and whether it's worth the cost.
Best Time to Buy a Tesla
Discover the optimal timing for purchasing a Tesla to maximize savings.
Used Tesla Buying Guide
Everything you need to know about buying a pre-owned Tesla safely.