Choosing Between Tesla's Most Popular Models
The Model 3 and Model Y share 75% of their parts but serve different needs. The Model 3 starts at $36,990 as a sleek sedan, while the Model Y starts at $39,990 as a versatile crossover with 3x more cargo space.
Quick Comparison
Model 3
Model Y
Real-World Owner Experience
Sarah's Decision: After test driving both models, Sarah chose the Model Y despite the $3,000 price difference. As a weekend outdoor enthusiast with two kids, the extra cargo space (76 vs 24 cubic feet) and higher seating position were worth the trade-off of 28 fewer miles of range.
Her Model Y Long Range costs $44,990 and handles her 45-mile daily commute easily, while the fold-flat seats accommodate camping gear and sports equipment on weekends.
Detailed Comparison
Price and Value
Standard RWD Trims:
Model 3: $36,990 | Model Y: $39,990 ($3,000 difference)
Long Range AWD Trims:
Model 3: $42,490 | Model Y: $44,990 ($2,500 difference)
Performance Trims:
Model 3: $54,990 | Model Y: $51,490 (Model Y is $3,500 cheaper)
The Model 3 is generally more affordable, but the Model Y Performance offers better value at a lower price point than the Model 3 Performance.
Range and Efficiency
The Model 3 offers better range across all trims due to its more aerodynamic sedan design. The Long Range Model 3 achieves 358 miles compared to the Model Y's 330 miles—a 28-mile advantage.
For daily commuting under 50 miles, this difference is negligible. Both models charge at similar speeds (250kW for Model 3, 225kW for Model Y Standard).
Space and Practicality
Cargo Space: The Model Y offers 76 cubic feet of cargo space (68 cu ft with seats folded), compared to the Model 3's 24 cubic feet. That's more than 3x the storage capacity.
Seating: The Model 3 seats 5 passengers, while the Model Y offers an optional 7-seat configuration. The Model Y's higher seating position provides better visibility and easier entry/exit.
Dimensions: The Model Y is 4 inches longer, 3 inches taller, and offers significantly more headroom and cargo flexibility.
Performance and Handling
The Model 3 is quicker and more agile. The Standard RWD Model 3 reaches 0-60 mph in 5.8 seconds versus 6.8 seconds for the Model Y—a full second faster.
The Model 3's lower center of gravity and sedan design provide sportier handling and a more engaging driving experience. The Model Y prioritizes comfort and practicality over performance.
Features and Technology
Both models share the same core technology: 15.4-inch touchscreen, Autopilot, over-the-air updates, and Tesla's latest software. The Long Range and Performance trims offer identical premium features.
Standard Trim Differences: Both Standard models have reduced features (7-speaker audio, manual steering, textile trim, no rear screen), but the Model Y Standard also lacks the HEPA filter and has an enclosed glass roof with fabric headliner.
Reliability and Warranty
The Model 3 has a slightly higher predicted reliability rating (74 vs 69 from J.D. Power). Both vehicles come with a 4-year/50,000-mile limited warranty and an 8-year/120,000-mile battery and powertrain warranty.
The Model 3's simpler sedan design may result in fewer potential issues compared to the Model Y's more complex crossover architecture.
Which One Should You Choose?
Choose Model 3 If:
- • You want the lowest price ($36,990 starting)
- • Maximum range is important (358 miles)
- • You prefer sporty handling and performance
- • You don't need much cargo space
- • You want better efficiency and lower charging costs
- • You prefer a sleek sedan design
- • You're a single person or couple without kids
Choose Model Y If:
- • You need cargo space (76 cu ft vs 24 cu ft)
- • You have kids or pets
- • You want easier entry/exit with higher seating
- • You need 7-seat capability (optional)
- • You prefer SUV/crossover styling
- • You want better visibility from higher position
- • You haul gear for outdoor activities
Frequently Asked Questions
Related Articles
Model 3 Standard vs Long Range
Compare Model 3 trim levels to find the best value
Model Y Standard vs Long Range
Detailed comparison of Model Y configurations
Tesla Resale Value and Depreciation
How Model 3 and Model Y hold their value over time
Total Cost of Ownership
Calculate the true cost of owning each model